In late October 2026, Ontario’s Ministry of Health mailed letters to physicians whose billing patterns were unusually high compared with those of similar doctors. The Ontario Medical Association (OMA) says hundreds of physicians received the letters, although the Ministry has not publicly disclosed the total number. The OMA has demanded an apology.
The dispute is not about whether Ontario should watch how it spends public money. It is about whether an effort to find questionable billing is also catching doctors who are simply doing a great deal of legitimate work.
The letters are not audits. Based on descriptions published by physicians, health lawyers and the OMA, the letters do not appear to demand repayment, medical records or a formal response. But they say further review may follow, and the Ministry has not explained how it chose the recipients.
Why Are Doctors Upset?
The letter is dated October 27, 2026, and came from the Ministry’s Payment Accountability and Fraud Control Unit, according to Quinte News. Reporting describes it as saying a physician’s billing is higher than that of doctors with similar practice profiles. Depending on the version, it cites either a high number of days worked in a year or a high number of patients in a day.
The letter also says such patterns are uncommon and warrant careful review, acknowledges there may be legitimate explanations, and says further review may occur if the pattern continues. The letters described so far contained no individual figures. Sovereign Canadian has not obtained the complete letter, so this account relies on the original reporting.
Dr. Adam Stewart, a family physician in Madoc, told CTV News he cares for about 1,700 patients and is in his electronic medical records nearly every day. He found the letter intimidating and wants an apology.
Dr. Sahil Koppikar, a Toronto rheumatologist, told Healthy Debate his Toronto clinics typically see 8 to 18 patients, and some Timmins outreach clinics see 20 to 25. His letter cited patients per day.
These are the doctors’ own accounts, not audited descriptions of their billing. Patients billed and patients seen in person can be different measures, so clinic sizes alone do not show the screening was wrong.
Why Is Ontario Looking at Physician Billing?
Because the Auditor General of Ontario found real problems. Her December 2025 report noted that Ontario paid about CAD 19.5 billion to physicians in 2024/25. Only eight Ministry staff conducted post-payment audits, which check claims after the money has been paid, and those audits relied mainly on tips and complaints rather than data analysis.
The report found that 82 physicians billed for 24 or more hours of services on at least one day in 2024/25, up from 59 in 2022/23. In one case, a physician billed 114 hours of services in a single day. A subsequent audit identified nearly CAD 1.4 million in overpayments associated with that physician’s billing. The Auditor General recommended better data analytics and a risk-based approach to choosing who gets audited, and the Ministry agreed.
Hours billed under time-based OHIP codes do not necessarily correspond to the number of hours a physician physically worked that day. The report describes a physician who billed group counselling sessions as individual ones, inflating the total.
The Auditor General also did not conclude that every high-billing pattern was improper. “There may be valid reasons for billing a large number of hours a day,” she wrote, but without flagging such cases, the Ministry cannot tell.
What Does the Government Say?
The Ministry told CTV News the outreach is educational and “does not assume billing was inappropriate.” Health Minister Sylvia Jones called the letters part of the Ministry’s standard review of unusual billing patterns and said doctors will not face action if their work was done and billed appropriately.
The Ministry’s own post-payment audit process, prepared with the OMA, lists a “billing education letter” as one possible outcome of a preliminary review, alongside taking no action or starting a full audit. A full audit is a different step, involving a formal request for records and a path that can end in repayment. Available reporting does not establish that receiving one of these letters initiates a formal post-payment audit.
One caution. The Auditor General did not recommend these letters. Her report urged better analytics and described education letters the Ministry already sends, but nobody has shown how that earlier activity relates to the October mailing.
Could This Discourage Legitimate Medical Care?
This is the OMA’s central fear. Ontario already struggles to connect people with family doctors and specialists, and the OMA says warning doctors about high volume could make them less willing to take on patients or work extra hours. OMA President Dr. Rebecca Hicks said the letters are disheartening for physicians already working evenings, weekends and holidays. The association predicts a “chilling effect.”
That is a prediction. Dr. Koppikar said he and colleagues are now less willing to take on extra work, which is a sign of mood rather than measured change. Through November 16, no documented reduction in appointments or working hours attributable to the letters had been reported.
High billing volume can mean several things: legitimate extra care, differences between specialties and payment models, indirect or administrative work that some models pay for, billing errors, or inappropriate claims. The public record does not show how well the Ministry’s screening tells these apart.
What Remains Unanswered?
Several basic questions have no public answer. How many physicians received letters? What exact criteria triggered them? How are doctors compared with peers, and do the comparisons account for specialty, payment model, rural service and indirect care? Can recipients see the data behind their letter?
The Ministry told CTV News that billing more than 15 hours of services or more than 100 unique patients in a day counts as abnormal. But the letters cited days worked or patients, and nothing establishes that these were the exact criteria used in October.
The Ministry may well have safeguards it has not described, and an undisclosed method is not proof of a flawed one. Still, without more detail, neither physicians nor taxpayers can judge it.
The Sovereign Canadian View
Ontario is right to pursue improper billing. Billions of public dollars are at stake, and the Auditor General’s findings are real. But a doctor who works a heavy schedule should not be discouraged just because the workload differs from that of peers. The Ministry should tell physicians and the public how its screening separates unusual billing from inappropriate billing, starting with how many letters went out and what triggered them. The controversy is about the quality and transparency of oversight, not whether oversight should exist.
