A vehicle is one of the largest recurring capital expenditures a Canadian household makes, and it is also one of the least carefully analysed. Most attention goes to the sticker price and the monthly payment. Far less goes to the quantities that quietly decide the lifetime cost: how much value the vehicle loses, how often it is replaced, what it consumes in fuel and maintenance, what insurance costs as it ages, and what the money tied up in the vehicle could have done elsewhere. Two households with identical incomes can end up with very different balance sheets depending on how often they replace a car, and neither may have chosen deliberately.
The usual advice comes in two confident versions. One says that a new car loses a fortune the moment it leaves the lot and that only fools buy them. The other says that an old car is a repair bill waiting to happen and that peace of mind justifies the premium. Both contain something true, and both are usually asserted without a full accounting. This article compares new, five-year-old and ten-year-old vehicles, bought and held for different lengths of time, across four very different vehicles, and asks what the numbers support and what they do not. The conclusions are less tidy than either slogan.
Continue reading